How stupid are they!!!".
Here is my reasoning.
Why was it right decision to let Saquon walk?It’s simple.

The Giants were not competitive as structured and Saquon did not change that.
Making him the 3rd highest paid RB in the league would put them right where they were last year.
Saquon was a luxury, not a foundation.

But Saquon is doing so well!No shit.
Going to the Eagles would not be a downgrade for any active RB in the league.
But the Giants decided to pay Daniel Jones instead of Saquon!That is demonstratively untrue.
Just go look at the money they spent in free agency.
It was never a this OR that situation.
Maybe they try free agency instead!
That puts them right back into “They paid X instead of Y!”
I’m sure he said the same thing about McKinney.
I’m sure every GM says that about every pending free agent they have in regard to division rivals.
Make fun of them for drafting bad!
Make fun of them for letting a non-luxury piece in Xavier McKinney walk.
All of these choices are bad.
But choosing to let Saquon walkthis offseasonwas not a bad decision.
Now get your Sierra Nevadas ready for tonight and start to Bolt Up.